Nestled in lower Manhattan, New York City's Little Italy brims with tradition, authentic flavors, and lively culture, offering a nostalgic taste of Italian-American heritage. With its charming streets, historic eateries, and culinary hotspots, this neighborhood transports you straight to the heart of Italy. From pasta perfection to classic pizzas and world-famous pastries, here's your guide to the best Little Italy restaurants in NYC.
The History of Little Italy in NYC
Little Italy began in the late 19th century as mainly southern Italian immigrants who settled in lower Manhattan. This neighborhood provided a sense of community where they could speak their language, celebrate traditions, and, importantly, savor the familiar flavors of home. Small businesses emerged, selling goods and foods that connected these newcomers to their roots, turning Little Italy into a thriving cultural and culinary hub.
By the early 20th century, Little Italy reached its peak, with Mulberry Street becoming the heart of Italian-American life. The neighborhood became famous for its eateries, where both locals and visitors could experience authentic Italian flavors. Events like the Feast of San Gennaro began as small religious celebrations and grew into popular public festivals, showcasing Italian music, food, and culture.
As the years passed, Little Italy shrank in size as Italian families moved to other parts of the city. Today, the neighborhood is primarily centered on Mulberry Street, maintaining its identity through historic restaurants and family-owned businesses that preserve old-world recipes and traditions. Visiting Little Italy today offers a chance to step into NYC's immigrant history and taste dishes that have been lovingly passed down through generations.
Savor the Best of Little Italy's Iconic Restaurants
From century-old establishments to modern favorites with classic recipes, Little Italy's restaurants showcase Italian-American heritage and culinary excellence.
Lombardi's Pizza: Where NYC Pizza Began
A true legend, Lombardi's Pizza holds the distinction of being the first pizzeria in the U. S., having served locals and visitors since 1905. Famous for its coal-fired, thin-crust pizza, Lombardi's remains a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Must-Try Dish: Go for their classic Margherita pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and San Marzano tomato sauce for an unforgettable slice.
Rubirosa Ristorante: A Family Recipe Legacy
Just a short walk from Little Italy's central streets, Rubirosa Ristorante is known for its thin-crust pizzas and handmade pasta, prepared using recipes passed down over generations. This family-run spot is beloved for its cozy atmosphere and flavorful Italian-American dishes.
Must-Try Dish: The Tie Dye™ Pizza, a unique spin with vodka sauce, pesto, and fresh mozzarella, is a crowd-pleaser, while their homemade pasta dishes, especially the ricotta ravioli, showcase authentic Italian flavors.
Da Nico Ristorante: An Iconic Italian Experience
Located in the heart of Little Italy, Da Nico is a neighborhood staple. Known for its inviting garden seating, it's a top choice for anyone looking to enjoy authentic Italian food in a lively setting. Da Nico has a classic menu filled with Italian comfort foods that will leave you coming back for more.
Must-Try Dish : Sample the rigatoni alla vodka, made with creamy tomato vodka sauce, or enjoy their famous wood-fired pizza for a classic NYC experience.
Casa D'Angelo: A Little Italy Institution
Open since 1902, Casa D'Angelo (formerly known as Angelo's of Mulberry Street) stands as one of Little Italy's oldest and most beloved Italian restaurants. With its warm, traditional decor and classic Italian-American dishes, Casa D'Angelo continues to capture the authentic spirit of the neighborhood.
Must-Try Dish: Try their signature veal parmigiana or linguine vongole — a linguine dish with fresh clam sauce.
Puglia: An Italian Party Atmosphere
For more than 100 years, Puglia has served as a gathering place for families and friends who want a lively dining experience in Little Italy. With a focus on southern Italian cuisine, Puglia's specialties include rich pasta dishes and classic Italian meats. The restaurant's energetic atmosphere often features live music, making it ideal for groups.
Must-Try Dish: Their chicken marsala, with tender chicken cutlets in a rich marsala wine sauce, is a highlight. For pasta lovers, the rigatoni alla vodka provides a creamy, savory delight.
Caffe Napoli: Cozy and Authentic
If you're seeking an intimate spot with Italian café charm, Caffe Napoli is a perfect choice. This charming eatery is a great place to relax, enjoy an espresso, and savor some of the best pasta in Little Italy.
Must-Try Dish: The spaghetti alla carbonara, rich with egg yolk and pancetta, is a must, while their seafood pasta also delivers fresh and flavorful bites of the Italian coast.
Gelso & Grand: Modern Vibes With a Traditional Touch
Gelso & Grand blends modern dining with classic Italian flavors, adding an innovative twist to traditional recipes. Known for its lively, trendy atmosphere, Gelso & Grand is an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and larger gatherings.
Must-Try Dish: Don't miss their truffle pacchieri — a creamy, aromatic dish with a unique twist. Their signature meatballs, served as an appetizer, are also wildly popular.
Ferrara Bakery & Café: The Sweet Finale
No trip to Little Italy would be complete without a stop at Ferrara Bakery & Café, an institution dating back to 1892. Known for its cannoli, gelato, and espresso, Ferrara provides a sweet end to any Little Italy visit.
Must-Try Dish: The cannoli at Ferrara is a staple. Each bite brings a perfect blend of creamy filling and crisp pastry shell. Try their assortment of Italian pastries, including sfogliatelle and biscotti, paired with a robust espresso for an authentic Italian treat.
For more things to do around Little Italy, check out the top 10 things to do in New York for nearby attractions and activities.
Practical Tips for Visiting Little Italy
Little Italy can get quite busy, especially during weekends and during popular events like the San Gennaro Feast. Here are a few tips for a smooth visit:
- Best Time To Visit : Early in the day or midweek offers a quieter experience, allowing you to fully enjoy the area's charm.
- Reservations : Making a reservation can save you time, especially for popular spots like Lombardi's and Casa D'Angelo.
- Wear Comfortable Shoes : Little Italy's charm is best experienced on foot. From strolling down Mulberry Street to browsing nearby shops and restaurants, you'll want comfortable shoes to explore.
- Bring Cash : While many places accept cards, some smaller eateries and shops may be cash-only, so it's helpful to have cash on hand for quick purchases.
- Nearby Attractions : Little Italy is close to Chinatown and SoHo, making it easy to explore these neighborhoods during your visit.
Why Little Italy NYC Is Worth Visiting
Little Italy remains a must-visit in NYC due to its cultural heritage, historic restaurants, and authentic flavors. From the oldest pizzeria in the U.S. to bakeries that have preserved Italian dessert traditions for over a century, this neighborhood offers a taste of Italy that feels both nostalgic and fresh. Whether you're craving pizza, pasta, or just a great cannoli, Little Italy is a culinary treasure trove with a story behind every dish.
For even more ways to explore New York City, check out how you can save up to at New York City's top things to do with CityPASS® tickets.
New York City Lodging
To get the most out of your stay in New York City, we recommend finding lodging near New York City's top attractions. Use this map to find the right lodging for you:
Booking.com